Doing an Independent Study with Dr. Wimpy
So you need an independent study?
I am often approached by students who want to complete an independent study with me. In most cases, they “want” to do this because they “need” a certain amount of credit for a given sub-field to graduate. In other cases it is a matter of convenience in scheduling or professor.
While I understand these issues, an independent study should be much more than just a way to fulfill degree requirements. Here’s what I look for and expect:
What Makes a Good Independent Study
Clear Research Question: You should have a specific research question or topic you want to explore in depth. “I need comparative politics credits” is not a research question.
Genuine Interest: I want to see that you’re genuinely curious about the topic, not just trying to check a box.
Preparatory Work: You should have already done some background reading and have a sense of the existing literature.
Realistic Scope: The project should be ambitious enough to be worthwhile but manageable given the time constraints.
The Application Process
When you approach me about an independent study, please include:
A 1–2 page proposal outlining:
- Your research question
- Why you’re interested in this topic
- Preliminary literature you’ve identified
- Your proposed methodology/approach
- Expected deliverables
Your academic background relevant to the topic
Your timeline and how this fits with your other commitments
What to Expect
Regular Meetings: We’ll meet bi-weekly to discuss progress, challenges, and next steps.
Substantial Reading: Expect to engage with 15–20 academic sources minimum.
Written Work: Usually a substantial research paper (20–30 pages) or equivalent project.
Presentation: You may be asked to present your work to other students or faculty.
When I Say No
I may decline to supervise an independent study if:
The proposal lacks focus or genuine engagement.
You haven’t demonstrated preparatory work.
The topic falls too far outside my expertise.
I don’t have the bandwidth to provide adequate supervision.
Alternative Suggestions
If an independent study isn’t the right fit, consider:
Directed readings courses for exploring a literature
Research assistant positions to gain hands-on experience
Thesis work if you’re looking for a capstone experience
Existing courses that might meet your needs
Remember: an independent study should be an intellectually rewarding experience for both of us. If you’re just looking to fulfill requirements, there are likely better options available.